Connect with us

Opinion

CNN, MSNBC hosts fail to update viewers after promoting botched NPR report on SCOTUS feud

Published

on

A few of the greatest stars on CNN and MSNBC peddled the debunked narrative alleging Supreme Courtroom Justices Neil Gorsuch and Sonia Sotomayor have been feuding over masks. 

The liberal media went wild on Tuesday after NPR revealed a report claiming that Sotomayor was working remotely due to Gorsuch’s refusal to put on a masks regardless of all of the justices having been requested by Chief Justice John Roberts to take action as a result of Sotomayor having diabetes, making her weak to COVID. 

NPR, NINA TOTENBERG RIPPED FOR DEFIANTLY STANDING BY SUPREME COURT MASK REPORT AFTER SWIFT BLOWBACK

MSNBC star Pleasure Reid advised viewers Tuesday that Gorsuch “loves COVID — which makes him the proper Republican” and thinks “little or no” of pandemic precautions, calling him a “rotten co-worker, harmful to be close to in the course of the pandemic and tonight’s absolute worst.”

“All In” host Chris Hayes known as the NPR report a “stunning story” and slammed Gorsuch’s “deeply obnoxious conduct.”

CNN anchor Anderson Cooper took a swipe at Gorsuch, noting that the affiliate justice who “lately wrote a e book decrying the dearth of civility within the nation.” He then spoke with CNN correspondent Ariane de Vogue, who mentioned she confirmed NPR’s reporting although she acknowledged she didn’t know what Roberts did with Sotomayor’s voiced concern about unmasked colleagues. 

Cooper learn an excerpt from Gorsuch’s e book “If You Can Maintain It,” which he wrote partly, “to be worthy of our freedoms, all of us should undertake civic habits that allow others to get pleasure from them too.” The anchor known as it “attention-grabbing,” suggesting Gorsuch was responsible of being a civility hypocrite. 

LIBERAL MEDIA POUNCED ON GORSUCH BEFORE CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS, SOTOMAYOR DEBUNKED VIRAL NPR REPORT

CNN’s Don Lemon later reported on the “COVID masks controversy” on the Supreme Courtroom as reported by his community. 

On Wednesday morning, CNN’s “New Day” invited NPR’s chief authorized affairs correspondent Nina Totenberg, who authored the botched report, to speak concerning the so-called feud. 

CNN’s Kasie Hunt requested “What’s up with Justice Gorsuch?” including “If all of the other- together with all the opposite conservative justices on the Supreme Courtroom are prepared to associate with this, why not him?”

Nina Totenberg at NPR headquarters in Washington, D.C., Might 21, 2019. (picture by Allison Shelley)
(Allison Shelley/NPR)

It wasn’t till later that Gorsuch and Sotomayor issued a joint assertion declaring the report “false,” which was adopted by one other assertion from Roberts additionally debunking the story.

MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” and “Deadline: White Home” offered updates to their viewers with the three justices’ statements on Thursday after they initially ran with NPR’s report.

CNN anchor John King, who didn’t beforehand report on NPR’s story, reported on the statements rebuking NPR.

NPR PUBLIC EDITOR ADMITS SCOTUS STORY ‘MERITS CLARIFICATION,’ SAYS REPORTER’S WORD CHOICE WAS ‘MISLEADING’

Nonetheless, neither King’s CNN colleagues within the morning nor primetime have offered any replace to their viewers, in response to Grabien transcripts. MSNBC’s Reid and Hayes equally have averted any protection of the fabricated controversy since Tuesday. 

CNN nor MSNBC instantly responded to Fox Information’ requests for remark. 

In the meantime, Fox Information’ Shannon Bream set the story straight forward of the justices, showing on Tuesday’s “Particular Report” and saying that NPR was “not correct,” in response to a supply, including there was by no means a request by Roberts for everybody to put on masks, Sotomayor by no means made such a request to Gorsuch and Gorsuch by no means refused to put on a masks. 

Supreme Court justices Neil Gorsuch and Sonia Sotomayor issued a joint statement calling an NPR report "false." 

Supreme Courtroom justices Neil Gorsuch and Sonia Sotomayor issued a joint assertion calling an NPR report “false.” 
(Reuters)

NPR repeatedly defended its report each after the Gorsuch-Sotomayor assertion and the Roberts assertion, telling Fox Information it was standing by Totenberg’s report. 

Totenberg doubled down on her reporting, writing in a follow-up article, “What’s incontrovertible is that each one the justices have directly began carrying masks—besides Gorsuch. In the meantime, Justice Sotomayor has stayed out of the courtroom. As a substitute, she has participated remotely within the court docket’s arguments and the justices’ weekly convention, the place they focus on the circumstances and vote on them.”

NPR public editor Kelly McBride admitted on Thursday that Totenberg’s report “deserves clarification,” saying her use of the phrase “requested” when reporting that Roberts had requested his colleagues to put on masks was “deceptive,” saying that the phrase “suggesting” would have been extra correct. 

The veteran NPR journalist dismissed McBride’s criticism herself in an interview with the Every day Beast. 

“She will write any goddamn factor she needs, whether or not or not I believe it’s true … she’s not clarifying something,” Totenberg mentioned. “I haven’t even checked out it, and I don’t care to take a look at it as a result of I report back to the information division, she doesn’t report back to the information division.”

Totenberg didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark from Fox Information Digital. 

Fox Information’ Brian Flood contributed to this report.